HOME SEARCH RESOURCES CONTACT
 
Who was Proskauer?
 
 
 

JUDGE JOSEPH MEYER PROSKAUER
(1877-1971)

"In all the history of Proskauer Rose," Walter Mendelsohn (a former name partner of the Firm) once said, "there was only one legal genius, and that was Proskauer. He was the greatest lawyer I ever knew."

Joseph M. Proskauer was born in Mobile, Alabama on August 6, 1877, a descendant of immigrant merchants who had settled in Mobile before the Civil War. He arrived in New York City at the age of 15 to attend Columbia College, from which he was graduated in 1896. In 1899, he received his law degree from Columbia Law School, and formed a partnership with James N. Rosenberg, a close friend. In 1902, the firm merged into James, Schell & Elkus, headed by Abram I. Elkus, and later known as Elkus, Gleason & Proskauer.

Through his association with Elkus, later a judge of the New York State Court of Appeals, Joseph Proskauer became acquainted with New York Governor Alfred E. Smith, and served as his campaign adviser, speechwriter, golfing partner and friend, until Governor Smith's death in 1944. Proskauer is credited with authoring Franklin D. Roosevelt's "Happy Warrior" speech, nominating Governor Smith for the presidency in 1924, and with assisting the Governor in his fight against religious bigotry during the 1928 presidential campaign. When Governor Smith's relationship to President Roosevelt and the New Deal deteriorated, Proskauer remained loyal to Smith, whom he called "the best and the wisest man I ever knew."

"He was the greatest lawyer I ever knew."

Governor Smith appointed Joseph Proskauer to fill an unexpired term on the New York State Supreme Court in June 1923. That November, he was elected to a full term, and, in 1927, was appointed an associate justice of the Appellate Division, First Department. Realizing by late 1929 that "by instinct I was an advocate," Judge Proskauer decided to resign from the bench to return to private practice. He joined the Firm of Rose & Paskus, renamed Proskauer, Rose & Paskus, on March 11, 1930, and remained there for the next 40 years.

Judge Proskauer transformed the Firm. "The breadth of matters that got handled changed," remarked partner Alfred Appel. Added Walter Mendelsohn, "[Proskauer] brought in, not only a new level, but the top level of clientele in this world. He didn't bring them with him when he came to the Firm. They came after he was with the Firm." The Judge resisted practicing corporate law or performing administrative duties preferring to leave that to other members of the Firm. "You know," he told a client, "I only do trial work, I only handle the trial work."

Among the cases that Judge Proskauer considered his most significant were the defense of National City Bank in lawsuits seeking recovery of confiscated assets following the Russian Revolution; the defense of directors of the bank as a result of losses incurred in Cuban sugar investments after World War I; the representation of the Warner brothers against shareholders who argued that payments to the brothers were excessive after the development of talking pictures; the representation of Lee, Higginson & Company during the International Match Company frauds; and the Harriman Bank receivership. Judge Proskauer tried cases into his late 70s, including the massive Caltex litigation which concerned the sale of Saudi Arabian oil to European countries under the Marshall Plan.

Judge Proskauer's philanthropic and civic endeavors were as notable as his legal career. As president of the 92nd Street YM-YWHA from 1926 to 1931, he led the campaign to construct its headquarters building. He served as president of the Federation of Jewish Philanthropies from 1931 to 1935, as a member of the New York City Charter Revision Commission in 1935 and as chairman of the New York State Crime Commission from 1951 to 1953. As president of the American Jewish Committee from 1943 to 1949, he participated in the emotional debates concerning the establishment of the state of Israel. Among his proudest achievements was his role as a consultant to the founding conference of the United Nations and his contribution to its adoption of the Declaration of Human Rights.

Judge Proskauer received honorary degrees from numerous institutions, including Columbia, Dartmouth, Brandeis, New York University, Colgate and Fordham. At the age of 94, he died in New York City on September 10, 1971.

 
   
  ^top